The Boatyard Grill

Nestled right on the waterfront at 525 Old Taughannock Blvd, The Boatyard Grill in Ithaca, NY, offers an exquisite dining experience that brilliantly captures the essence of fresh, vibrant seafood and hearty American classics. This restaurant masterfully combines the inviting warmth of a welcoming local spot with the elegance of a refined dining destination—an ideal place for both special occasions and casual, memorable meals.

The cuisine at The Boatyard Grill centers on seafood with a bold, flavorful twist. Signature dishes like the Seafood Fra Diavolo, brimming with jumbo shrimp, tender calamari, and bay scallops tangled in a spicy arrabbiata sauce with toasted capers, create a thrilling harmony of spice and oceanic sweetness. Equally enticing, the Orange Glazed Halibut presents a delicate balance of citrus and savory notes, paired perfectly with jasmine rice and fresh vegetables, evoking bright, refreshing flavors with every bite.

For those craving meat, the steaks here do not disappoint. From the smoky, rich Maker’s Mark Sirloin drizzled with bourbon sauce and paired with rosemary mashed potatoes, to the decadent 8oz. Filet Mignon accompanied by a luxurious horseradish cream sauce, The Boatyard Grill delivers tender, expertly cooked cuts that satisfy steak lovers with nuance and depth.

Small plates and starters like the Georgia Peach Grilled Chicken, the indulgent Lobster Mac and Cheese, and the addictively creamy Spinach Artichoke Dip set the perfect stage for a relaxed yet elevated dining experience. The menu even caters to those seeking lighter options, with dishes like the ‘Naked’ Parmesan Crusted Salmon, offering a clean yet flavorful profile.

Atmosphere plays an essential role at The Boatyard Grill. As repeatedly praised by diners such as Zack T and Micah Dunham, the outdoor seating area boasts breathtaking views of the water, creating a serene backdrop where guests can savor the fresh air alongside their meal. Whether basking in sunset hues on the patio or enjoying the softly lit interior, the vibe is effortlessly charming and soothing, making every visit feel special.

Service here is consistently attentive and warm—guests like Diana Argueta and Melissa S. highlight staff members who strike the perfect balance between professional attentiveness and friendly hospitality. Recommendations like the Lobster & Shrimp Risotto or the Campfire Ribeye often come from knowledgeable servers who genuinely care about enhancing your culinary journey.

From the first bite of the coconut shrimp—crispy, sweet, and perfectly spiced—to the decadent chocolate cake for two that rounds out the evening like a comforting embrace, The Boatyard Grill is an authentic gem that delivers on every level. With its unparalleled combination of expertly crafted dishes, inviting waterfront views, and attentive service, this restaurant isn’t just a meal—it’s a memorable experience that beckons you back again and again.